Life's a Stitch

And more recently life’s a creative adventure with some travel thrown in.

Couldn't sleep last night. So I got up at 4:00a.m. and did some math. It's about Noro Silk Garden.

6a00d83451d51369e200e54f8099748834-640wi

Problem: If one knitter, myself, knit eleven projects out of said yarn, 42 skeins of conventional Silk Garden and eight of Silk Garden Sock yarn, how many silken gardeny miles were knit? 

Answer: 4.1 miles or 6.6 kilometers = 7217 yards or 6600 meters. 

And I have 26 skeins left in my stash. We're not going to do a cost analysis because most were bought on sale or on ebay, but still, it's frightening to even think about it.

Now, with all this Noro experience, I thought I'd write a review of sorts. The pros and cons of Noro Silk Garden:

Pros: 

  • A multitude of colours – it's like knitting with a rainbow. Particularly beautiful for entrelac, diagonal designs and modular techniques. Just look at that photo above. Remember my first oversized Lady Eleanor AKA my office blankie? Those colours make my knitting glands salivate. Here's another one.  And another, in the same colours.
  • Can often be found on sale.
  • It scores high on the drape factor.

Cons:

  • Knots – up to four per skein. I hear that that's the acceptable limit according to their quality control standards. However, along with the knots come abrupt colour changes sometimes necessitating adjustments to the order of colours being used, requiring the joining of a different skein and leaving more ends to weave that anticipated.
  • Detritus – straw, twigs, bits of fluff.
  • Disintegrating yarn – occasional sections of unspun fluff that pulls apart with the tiniest of tugs.
  • Thick and thin qualities – most people really hate this, but I don't mind the varied texture it produces.
  • The finer the yarn, the rougher the feel. Regular Silk Garden is softer than the sock yarn. It does soften with age and washing.

I look at these lists and wonder why anyone would bother to knit with it.  What can I say? Its beauty trumps its shortcomings. And writing this was an alternative to counting sheep. Good night.

Posted in

18 responses to “The Pros and Cons of Noro”

  1. Carole Avatar

    I think it’s all about the color. When you take that out of the equation it’s not great yarn at all!

    Like

  2. Mariann Avatar

    Loved this post. And I too found similar issues, but I just love how the colors flow with each stitch in a pattern. I know I will continue to purchase and knit with Noro,leaving the cons in the shadows. The recipients of knitted gifts don’t need to know 🙂

    Like

  3. Beverly Avatar

    I agree with you and the other commenters….the color is the thing! The Brooklyn Tweed striped scarf is the only “long skinny rectangle” I’ve ever finished and it was because of the Noro. Pulling out bits of grass from time to time was a pain…and running into a knot that changed colors drastically was also a pain…but I’m willing to put up with it too for the end product!

    Like

  4. Kimberly Avatar

    I have some Silk Garden that I bought years ago to make Klaralund. I hate it.
    I LOVE the colors. I love the stiping. I hate the texture, the knots, and the odd matter.
    Eventually though, I will use the yarn for something.

    Like

  5. Teresa James Avatar
    Teresa James

    I love the colours as well! I don’t mind a little detritus and unevenness in the yarn – reminds you that it is a natural product. I twist yarn as I knit, it seems, so I don’t usually have trouble with it pulling apart.
    I often get up at 4:30 am, look on the computer, then go back to bed. Must be our age!

    Like

  6. Allison Avatar

    I hope you slept better!
    I agree that the yarn itself is not so great, but the colors are spectacular and it does soften up nicely after a bath and gentle blocking. Seeing pictures of your Lady Eleanor is what inspired me to first look at Noro Silk Garden; while I still haven’t knit my own Lady Eleanor, I have the yarn stashed and will tackle it someday.

    Like

  7. Colleen Avatar
    Colleen

    I would like the Herringbone Rib scraf.
    Thank you so much for sharing this wonderful pattern

    Like

  8. Rebekah Avatar

    Its beuaty definitely does trump the bad things, but it is annoying a yarn that expensive has so many potentially bad qualities. I have some Noro Kabuto I recently discovered in mys tash, I think I’m going to use it as weft in a weaving project as there is not enough to actually knit something with that would be useful. Well wait, unless i make another clapotis with it! hmmm!

    Like

  9. Rebecca Avatar
    Rebecca

    I, too, would like the Herringbone Rib scarf pattern. All of your projects are beautiful!
    Thank you!

    Like

  10. Lucy Satchell Avatar
    Lucy Satchell

    I just found 3 skeins of T”ouch Me yarn in my stash and would love to try knitting the Herringbone rib scarf pattern. I had heard about the worming of the yarn while knitting and it was suggested that I do what you recommended…wash and dry for best results. May I have a copy of the pattern? Thank you for sharing the pattern … I will certainly have fun making it!

    Like

  11. Heather Avatar

    I’ve never been a noro fan. The texture throws me right off, and I find the colours garish. I’m not a fan of stripes. That being said, it does look lovely in entrelac! And there’s a beautiful entrelac tee in this summer’s Interweave. I just don’t know that I could wear something that scratchy…

    Like

  12. Désirée Avatar
    Désirée

    I honestly don’t know what the fuss is about Noro. Saw some for sale on Ravelry.. I think I know why she sold it. I’ve knitted a sweater and two scarves and won’t buy this yarn again. There are other yarns way cheaper and give as good results. I feel I’m wearing straw. I love the colors however there are amazing Noro alternatives with similar colors, softer and cheaper.

    Like

  13. Rachel M Avatar
    Rachel M

    I’m very new to this…Can anyone please tell me if there is a yarn that is in large color sections like the Noro Silk Garden Sock: Color 302? I dont know what to look for, but I cannot afford the original. Thank you in advance for your help.

    Like

  14. Kristy Avatar
    Kristy

    Any idea what colorway is used in the above picture? Thanks so much!!!

    Like

  15. Charlotte Duthie Avatar
    Charlotte Duthie

    Like other knitters I am put off by the texture, but I’m hoping washing will soften it up a bit. I also would like the pattern, pleasee. Thanks!

    Like

  16. ADELINA LIM Avatar
    ADELINA LIM

    Hi,
    I LOVE your entrelac blanket! The colours are beautiful! Can I please get the pattern for it? I just need to know how long and wide the blanket needs to be and how many skeins of yarn I need to purchase…..
    Regards,
    Adelina LIM

    Like

  17. Therese Madden-Fitzsimons Avatar
    Therese Madden-Fitzsimons

    I HATE it too. I’ve made several projects with it. I’m DONE now. The breakage, texture shifts, knots….there are so many other seriously gorgeous yarns available with beautiful coloring without the yarn texture variability, knots etc etc…Never again

    Like

  18. Kathy Boyd Avatar
    Kathy Boyd

    This is the first time using Noro..the world of nature. Considering the price, I really didn’t expect knots and what seemed like bits of straw. The colors were great.

    Like

Leave a reply to Heather Cancel reply